Currently reading: Fleet operators face rising fraud risks from electric vehicle charging

Self-reported energy use is leaving fleet managers in the dark about true costs

Almost half (44%) of electric vehicle fleets rely on drivers to report how much they’re spending on charging at home, a new survey has revealed – an oversight that’s leaving a growing share of operators exposed to the risk of expenses fraud.

The survey of 250 fleet, finance and procurement leaders, commissioned by mobility software firm Cubic3, found that 48% of them had expenses claims they couldn’t verify within the last 12 months.

Over the same period, 31% reported unauthorised transactions on company credit or fuel (and charging) cards, while 30% had at least one suspected or confirmed case of fraud.

Although 93% claimed they could identify unauthorised or fraudulent spend and 64% believed they had full visibility of costs, less than half (41%) said they have their expenses under control. A third (34%) had trouble tracking spend accurately across vehicles and drivers.

Electrification is adding to those challenges: 54% said EV charging was making payment and spend management more complicated – a process that already costs 171 hours per year, on average, according to the survey.

Accurately reimbursing home charging expenses has been a long-term challenge for fleets, which goes some way towards explaining why self-reporting ranked as the most popular method for claiming them back.

HMRC-approved advisory electric rates (AERs) are published every quarter, with separate per-mile rates for claiming back the cost charging at home and on public networks. 

AERs are designed as a no-quibble way to process expenses claims and are especially useful for home charging, where the cost of energy can be hard to separate from the rest of a household’s utility bill. 

However, they are approximate by nature. Drivers on an Ofgem-capped electricity tariff (26.3p per kWh) would need to average 3.8mpkWh (including charging losses) to break even with the 7p per-mile home charging AER. 

That same rate also massively over-reimburses drivers who can charge on tariffs with cheap overnight rates, which typically brings costs below 2p per mile. 

HMRC says operators can set their own rates, but they would need to prove that they reflect real-world costs or risk any excess being counted as untaxed income. However, only 20% of surveyed fleets said they use a tariff or meter to count the cost of home charging. 

With responses forecasting an average 49% EV share of their fleets within the next three years, that oversight risks becoming an increasingly large issue for operators, Cubic3 has warned.

Paul Foley, the company’s vice-president of in-vehicle payments, said: “The gap between confidence and control is the real finding. Fleets need to check a payment against company rules before it is made, not reconcile it after the money has gone.”

Join our WhatsApp community and be the first to read about the latest news and reviews wowing the car world. Our community is the best, easiest and most direct place to tap into the minds of Autocar, and if you join you’ll also be treated to unique WhatsApp content. You can leave at any time after joining - check our full privacy policy here.