Currently reading: Smart Roadster: spice up summer with a £1500 gem

The last 20 years have turned the Smart Roadster from annoying and expensive to quirky and cheap

The pauses didn’t help, nor not knowing quite when they’d come. And there was more than one kind of pause to be experienced aboard a Smart Roadster

The most obvious, and persistent, was the between-gears interruption generated by the automated manual transmission. The Roadster’s gearbox was not an especially speedy shuffler of clustered cogs and its six gears meant that, unless cruising, you’d experience perpetual ascents and descents of its generous ratio set. And if you left the ’box to think about its own shifting, you’d find that you were never quite ready for the moment when it chose to cut the power supply from the mid-mounted triple, even with familiarity.

There were dynamic hesitations too. This was an exceptionally light, mid-engined sports car that ought to have changed direction like a dragonfly. Spear a bend, and in the first instant you’d think it was going to do just that, the front wheels eagerly steering a new trajectory. But then the Smart’s athleticism would start to evaporate. You couldn’t call it understeer, but if you were expecting Lotus Elise balletics, well, you’d have to buy the real thing.

There was more, besides – the Roadster’s traction control dropping the curtain on any on-the-limit expeditions before they really started. It looked like a sports car, and an exciting one at that, but the Roadster’s cornerus interruptus methods protected its occupants from almost all kinds of on-the-road excitements. Still, after Mercedes’ adventures with toppling A-Classes and Smart Fortwos accelerating hard enough to land flat on their backs, you could understand the caution.

In plenty of other ways, though, the Roadster was the result of some admirably brave decisions. The bold Smart project wobbled for more than stability reasons, the two-seat city car falling massively short of sales expectations following its (delayed) 1998 debut, but that didn’t stop the Roadster project going ahead. Indeed, this dinky little device promised to deal with Smart’s mild glamour deficit.

It was also admirably true to the Fortwo’s construction concept. There was the so-called Tridion safety cell, this the pressed steel inner tub that provided a structure from which to hang the suspension, powertrain and a colourful collection of composite body panels. The engine was the same lively 698cc turbo triple that powered the Fortwo, its 80bhp impressive for one so small, and less burdened than it might have been with only 815kg to shove along.

The Roadster benefited from Smart’s appealingly distinct cabin furnishing schemes too, chunks of its dashboard sheathed with non-reflective cloth. Much of it was grey, but there were multiple shades of the stuff and you could give the interior ambience a cheerfully spectacular lift by specifying orange cloth. And like the Fortwo’s, the Roadster’s instrument pods were so shapely that you wanted to pick them up.

Back to top

In fact, the entire car was so shapely that you wanted to pick one up and take it home. Especially if it was the oddly named Roadster Coupé version, with its pertly curving fastback rump. The standard Roadster, this sadly the more common version, had a flat rear deck and a conventional boot, and looked more pick-up than convertible because it had B-pillars and a targa roof, like the Coupé. This electric roll-back fabric slice instantly opened the cabin to the sky, and if you stirred yourself, you could get out, remove the side panels, lock them into their under-bonnet slots and generate a real, windows-down breeze.

So with all this temptation, how to overcome those disappointing pauses? For the transmission, do your shifting manually. Then you’ll know when the pause is coming, just as you do in a car with a clutch. An optional sports wheel with paddles eases the process, and you can mitigate the jerks with some fancy (right) footwork. 

The dulled steering? There’s less you can do about that, but you soon adapt, and you’ll certainly enjoy the Roadster’s low centre of gravity, unwillingness to roll and grippy grip. Which, up to a point, gets you around the ESP interference.

Above all – and your reporter knows this, because his wife has one – this Smart is still great fun. It’s surprisingly brisk, comfortable, reasonably practical and not too noisy, the sounds emanating from behind in any case throbbily intriguing. Despite its flaws, the concept car-ish Roadster is sure to become a classic, especially as there aren’t huge numbers. Production ended after only three years and 43,400 units, sales undermined by the aforementioned issues, high pricing (for its size if not sophistication) and warranty costs that were alleged to reach €3000 per car. Water leaks were one reason.

Right now, around £2000 nets you the cheapest decent Roadster, which isn’t much for the resulting entertainment. And at the top end, £6000 will get you a low-mileage, hard-riding 100bhp Brabus, or a mint 80bhp survivor, a price that confirms their creeping desirability.

Join our WhatsApp community and be the first to read about the latest news and reviews wowing the car world. Our community is the best, easiest and most direct place to tap into the minds of Autocar, and if you join you’ll also be treated to unique WhatsApp content. You can leave at any time after joining - check our full privacy policy here.

Join the debate

Comments
2
Add a comment…
jason_recliner 13 July 2025
It's glacially slow with no room for passengers or luggage and the gearbox is the worst of all worlds. Where do I sign?
Peter Cavellini 12 July 2025

There one not far from me and it's a funky looking thing, just a shame it's let down by all these niggly annoying problems.