If you paid comfortably more than £50,000 for a brand-new car five years ago, and it had covered, say, 25,000 miles, would you be happy if it had issues?
The vehicle in question has been maintained regardless of cost and also kept it in showroom condition, which explains why its owner is a bit peeved. It's important to point out that the owner has always bought nice cars (always a few years old) and this is the latest in a fairly long line of prestigious motors.
The thing is that after a stiff £1000 service and repairs bill last year, the price has more than doubled this time around. That’s because the brake discs have warped for the second time in the car's life and there's an MOT issue because a bracket holding the exhaust has rusted through.
Because the exhaust is a single unit that includes the bracket, the whole thing needs to be replaced. The only option is an independent fabricator to knock something together.
Repairing cars is always expensive. Repairing expensive cars is really, really expensive. So I suppose the simple answer is to run a Shed 7-like vehicle.
Obviously, it would need better paintwork to please an owner who cared about cosmetics, but it sidesteps depreciation and means that money can be ploughed into the running costs. Clearly, this is an expense account car that gets fixed on the company books, so in the real world, without some bodging, it soon becomes obsolete and unsustainable.
Sorry that I can’t give you any more details – including names, model designations and dates – as this is an ongoing issue for the customer.
However, I’d be interested to hear about the biggest bill you may have been faced with for a repair, ideally on a car that was still fairly new. Oh, and whether you think five years old is acceptable for the big bills to start mounting up for a car. Any car, posh or not.
Join the debate
Add your comment
Depends what you call "Premium"
The Mercs and VAG's were at best average (comparable with Vauxhalls and Fords), but my current 1 series that I bought pre-registered with less than 20 miles recorded has now passed 75,000 miles and is still on its original brakes (front and rear) and wiper blades - it has just had routine servicing, tyres and 1 battery.
My previous BMW was an E46 Compact that I bought with under 3,000 miles and sold at 45,000 with routine servicing, new wiper blades, original brakes and battery.
And because they are built with some sensible engineering there are chain-driven camshafts so no new rubber bands!! Belts may be OK on non-interference engines like the old Ford Pinto in Mk3 to Mk5 Cortinas, Capris, etc. but on anything else they are surely a false economy.
I think you need to make a distinction between premium badge and premium engineering - Audis are still comparable with Skodas mechanically!
Interesting to read about JLR "reliability" on here when this website is showing me to a link to the 10 least depreciating cars and one is supposedly a Range Rover - well it might retain 50% or so of purchase price in 3 years but that assumes that you can stump up £80,000 or so to buy it in the first place and does not take into account all the repair bills it seems you can expect!! P.S. Why can't you put paragraphs in these blogs anymore?????
The pains of (almost any!) car ownership
Don't tar all dealers with same brush